Select the checkbox for the item that you'd like to have two winners for.

Scroll down to batch update, and select the duplicate option. 

The copy item will show in the manage items list.

Click on the item type to choose a live item type.

Silent
Live
Donation
Quantity
Blind
Credit
Info

You will see the two different items and item types. 

To determine the highest bid on the silent auction item, click on the green 'has bids' tag next to the active item's name.G

In the Butler, be sure to add the bids to the copy item (live item). 50% to one bidder and 50% to the other bidder.

130 - Apple Products Bundle - Copy of item 1

Live item types will allow you to add multiple winners at different amounts. 

Click the x and repeat the process until no bidders remain.

If you only remove the highest bidder, the next highest bidder will be considered the winner in the system. To avoid this, remove ALL of the bids on the silent auction item.

How to enter multiple winners for a silent item

Duplicate the Item

Split the Bid

Remove Silent Auction Bids