5 Leave Management Challenges & How to Overcome Them

Ajay Paghdal
July 20, 2023
min read
September 20, 2023
Photo credit
Discover 5 common hurdles in handling employee leave and proven strategies to overcome them effectively. Your guide to seamless HR management
Generate SOPs!


The alarm buzzes at 6:30 AM, and the ritual of a new workday begins.

You're ready to tackle whatever the corporate world throws your way. But then, a notification pops up on your phone—"John Doe—Sick Leave Request." Naturally, this comes as no real surprise. After all, it's a standard part of the HR professional's life.

But how well are you managing employee leave?

A recent study conducted in 2022 showed that around 35 percent of HR professionals believe leave management to be one of the most challenging aspects of their role. 

Keeping track of the time off requests while juggling:

  • Parental leave.
  • Sick leave.
  • Emergency leave.
  • Paid vacation

... or ensuring legal compliance with federal labor laws and the medical leave act, can be a daunting task.

In this blog, we'll look into the five most common challenges HR teams face in managing employee leave and provide actionable insights to help you navigate this complicated landscape.

Challenge 1: Keeping track of leave requests & balances

Imagine trying to juggle flaming torches while riding a unicycle—that's what keeping track of leave requests and balances can feel like for HR professionals. With a whirlwind of parental leave, paid time off, medical leave, and even jury duty, maintaining clear records can seem overwhelming. 

But this complex task is a crucial aspect of leave management, and mastering it can elevate your employee leave management to new heights.

Let's explore why it's vital and how to simplify the process.

Managing multiple leave requests at once

"Who's on vacation this week?" That's a question that HR managers often find themselves asking. Managing multiple leave requests simultaneously with a diverse workforce can feel like trying to solve a Rubik's Cube. 

Whether it's John from Marketing, who requested time off for a family vacation, Jane from sales, who's on medical leave, or even Alex from HR, who's away on parental leave, the constant churn of requests can be overwhelming.

There's also the added complexity of different types of leaves—paid, unpaid, emergency, and even unusual circumstances like jury duty. Each type comes with its own company policies and federal labor laws.

Lose track, and you could land in legal trouble or, at the very least, disrupt your business workflow.

Modern absence management systems can help streamline this process. These tools are a game-changer with advanced features that allow HR teams to manage employee leave efficiently. They can help you keep track of time off requests, leave balances, and ensure that all policies, from the company's policies to state and federal laws, are adhered to.

A well-organized leave management process can make all the difference. Ensuring the fulfillment of the HR department's responsibilities plays an integral role in safeguarding employee satisfaction and fostering a positive company culture.

Accurately recording & updating leave balances

Maintaining accurate records and consistently updating leave balances isn't just a task on an HR professional's to-do list; it's a cornerstone of effective leave management. This accuracy is integral to the company's smooth operation and the staff members' peace of mind. So, how can HR departments tackle this critical duty?

Different types of leave—paid vacation, sick leave, parental leave, unpaid leave, and jury duty—require different tracking mechanisms. The absence of a solid process can lead to numerous challenges, including payroll errors, staffing shortages, and potential violations of federal labor laws or the medical leave act.

Leave management systems aid in keeping track of leaves and their balances in real time, allowing HR teams to manage employee leave with precision and consistency. It minimizes the risk of management errors and facilitates adherence to company policies and legal compliance.

Ensuring the accurate recording and updating of leave balances promotes a transparent culture where employees have clear insights into their paid time off, and HR teams can manage leave requests efficiently and effectively.

Overcoming challenges with leave tracking systems or spreadsheets

When navigating the challenging seas of leave management, a reliable compass in a leave tracking system can make a world of difference. These systems have revolutionized the HR landscape, replacing the outdated spreadsheets and manual methods of yesteryears.

Employing solid leave tracking software can simplify managing employee leave. It can track parental leave, sick leave, paid vacation and even less common instances like jury duty. These systems can automate updating leave balances and managing time off requests, minimizing errors and ensuring accuracy.

Leave tracking software keeps HR professionals, team managers, and employees on the same page and aids in making informed decisions. It helps ensure your company complies with federal labor laws and company policies.

Challenge 2: Balancing staffing & workload

Managing employee leave is a mandatory part of maintaining this balance. If executed correctly, it could improve your workflow efficiency.

Let's look at how we can ensure this dance runs smoothly, even with the occasional missing dancer.

Maintaining productivity during employee absences

Picture this: It's crunch time, and your team is firing on all cylinders to meet a deadline. Suddenly, a key player calls in sick. How does your organization maintain productivity during such unexpected employee absences?

Managing employee leave involves a delicate balancing act—respecting employees' right to time off while ensuring that the company's staffing requirements are met.

Advanced leave or change management systems can be the saving grace in such scenarios. They facilitate keeping track of absences and leaves and help in strategic decision-making and planning for absent staff. When HR teams have a clear picture of leave schedules, they can better anticipate and prepare for staffing shortages, so that work continues smoothly.

Proactive planning, clear process documentation and effective leave management are the keys to productivity during employee absences.

Addressing workload imbalances caused by leave

Imagine a ship trying to navigate choppy waters with a few oarsmen missing. That's what workload imbalance caused by leave can feel like. But it doesn't have to be that way.

You can ensure your company ship stays on course by effectively managing employee leave and staffing requirements.

The first step towards addressing workload imbalances is adopting a proactive approach to leave management. Build SOPs for your HR team to rely on.

Knowing who's on leave and when helps HR teams and managers plan accordingly and redistribute the workload to ensure that no one is overwhelmed and no task is left unattended.

This is where the magic of SOPs and leave management software work together. Enable your teams to work quickly, and use your tools efficiently. Then, these sophisticated systems not only help in tracking leave requests and balances, but they also facilitate strategic decision-making. 

By providing a clear overview of leaves, they empower managers to manage employee leave to minimize disruption and maintain a fair distribution of tasks.

Challenge 3: Complying with legal & organizational policies

Walking the tightrope between legal and organizational policies while managing employee leave is no small feat. With many regulations like federal labor laws, the medical leave act, and company policies to consider, this task can seem daunting. 

Legalities and guidelines are not hurdles but signposts that ensure fair and consistent leave management practices. Compliance isn't a mere legal obligation but a reflection of your organization's values. 

Let's explore how we can navigate this aspect of leave management, ensuring fairness, transparency, and compliance.

Navigating complex labor laws & regulations

Navigating the labyrinth of labor laws and regulations while managing employee leave can sometimes feel like decoding an ancient script. Whether it's complying with federal labor laws, understanding the nuances of the medical leave act, or staying updated with changes in state labor laws, the complexities can be overwhelming.

Understanding these laws is primary for HR professionals. Proactively addressing legal concerns not only aids in preventing legal complications but also prioritizes preserving employees' rights. This, in turn, fosters a climate of trust and satisfaction among the team.

This is why you want to build your own internal procedures to make sure that everyone is following the letter of the law. Use am AI-powered tool like Scribe to capture your company's unique workflows to build instructions and training manuals in minutes.

Of course, staying up-to-date with local laws and regulations can be even more challenging for companies operating remotely, especially if they’re hiring international employees. In this case, using an employer of record (EOR) might be preferable, since it will remove some of the burden on in-house HR professionals to manage multiple international leave policies.


Combine your training materials with advanced leave management software. This will help you keep track of different types of leaves — be it parental leave, sick leave, or even unusual circumstances like jury duty. These procedures and systems ensure that the leave management process aligns with legal requirements and company policies.

🎓 Related Resource: Policy vs. Procedure: What's the Difference?

Adhering to company-specific leave policies & procedures

Each company has unique policies that reflect its values and culture, from parental to paid vacation, from sick to emergency leave. Navigating this terrain can be as complex as understanding federal or state labor laws.

Company policies are an essential guideline for HR teams and managers when managing employee leave. They help ensure consistency, prevent bias and provide a clear decision-making framework. Moreover, these policies also play a significant role in fostering employee satisfaction and maintaining a positive company culture.

HR professionals can effectively leverage leave management and other HR software to adhere to company-specific leave policies.

These systems help you track leaves and leave requests, maintain clear records, and ensure that all leave management processes align with the company's policies.

Complying with company-specific leave policies and procedures goes beyond a mere checkbox exercise. It's a commitment to upholding the organization's values, promoting fairness, and ensuring that every employee, regardless of their role or length of service, is treated fairly and equitably in leave matters.

🆓 Check out our free Policy and Procedure Template

Use HR software for automated policy enforcement

HR teams increasingly use technology to streamline their processes; leave management is no exception.

HR software, specifically leave management software, has revolutionized how organizations manage employee leave and sparked transformations in the HR department.

But how exactly does it facilitate automated policy enforcement?

Provide a centralized platform for all leave-related information. This includes tracking time off requests, leave balances, and even the types of parental, sick and vacation leave. This allows for seamless and accurate management of leaves, reducing the risk of errors.

Configured according to the company's policies, ensuring that every leave request processed aligns with the established guidelines. This automated policy enforcement promotes fairness and transparency in the leave management process and aids in legal compliance.

HR software allows easy access to leave records, ensuring HR teams, team managers and employees are on the same page. It promotes informed decision-making and boosts employee satisfaction.

Utilizing HR software for automated policy enforcement simplifies the leave management process and promotes a fair, transparent, and efficient workplace.

Challenge 4: Managing unexpected or prolonged leaves

Just as calm seas can suddenly turn stormy, an organization can face unexpected or prolonged leaves. Whether due to medical emergencies, parental leave, or even jury duty, such situations present unique challenges to managing employee leave.

With strategic planning and effective business process management, these seemingly stormy scenarios can be navigated successfully. 

Let's explore how we can turn these unexpected leaves from unwelcome surprises into manageable situations that respect employee rights and maintain business continuity.

Handling unplanned leaves due to emergencies or illness

Unplanned leaves due to emergencies or illnesses can pose challenges in managing the immediate staffing requirements, maintaining morale and ensuring employee satisfaction.

HR teams must walk the delicate line between meeting business needs and respecting the employee's situation. Sick or emergency leave isn't just an HR issue; it's a human issue. The leave management process should be empathetic, supportive and fair.

This is where clear rules, guidelines and leave management systems prove invaluable. By providing a clear record of employee leaves and facilitating quick responses to leave requests, these tools can help HR managers handle these situations effectively.

This includes managing the distribution of tasks among remaining staff members and maintaining clear communication with the affected employee.

In handling unplanned leaves due to emergencies or illness, remember that the goal isn't just to keep the business running. It's also about supporting your team members during difficult times. After all, a company's strength lies in its people, and how it treats them, especially in challenging times, speaks volumes about its values.

🎓 Related Resource: Team Management Best Practices That Could Help You Lead Today

Addressing long-term leaves & their impact on team dynamics

When a team member is absent for a prolonged period, it can lead to an increased workload for others, potentially causing stress and dissatisfaction. The team's rhythm and collaborative spirit can also be affected.

Effective leave management processes, powered by robust documentation and leave management software, can help HR teams navigate these challenges. These systems provide clear visibility into leave schedules, aiding in proactive planning. This allows for fair distribution of work so that no one feels overwhelmed.

Long-term leaves aren't just about managing workloads but also human relationships. It's vital to maintain open lines of communication with the absent staff member and the rest of the team.

A balanced, empathetic approach ensures the team stays cohesive and productive, even during prolonged absences.

Establishing clear communication channels for leave notification

A well-structured time-off management process helps manage leave and boosts employee satisfaction by providing transparency and a fair, accurate way to request time off.

Incorporating a robust leave management system can streamline this process by providing a centralized platform for leave notifications, balances and requests. These systems can be integrated into the employee handbook, making it easily accessible and straightforward.

These systems also play an important role in managing leave abuse. Maintaining precise records enables HR teams to identify patterns that may suggest misuse and address them according to the company's policy guidelines.

Clear communication channels allow for a smooth exchange of information regarding such benefits, giving employees peace of mind during a challenging time.

Transparency and fairness foster a positive work environment where employees feel valued and respected.

Challenge 5: Employee engagement & retention

But what role does leave management play in this scenario? More than you might think. From offering paid leave to ensuring a fair leave request process, the practices surrounding managing employee leave significantly impact employee satisfaction, engagement, and retention. 

Let's explore how we can organize our leave management policies to hit the high notes in employee engagement and retention.

Maintaining employee morale during leave periods

From granting paid leave to managing leave requests fairly and accurately, the leave management process can significantly impact employee morale and satisfaction.

An efficient leave management system can make this process smoother, ensuring employees feel valued and respected. Companies can encourage trust and transparency by providing clear guidelines on requesting time off and managing leave per policy guidelines outlined in the employee handbook.

Health insurance benefits, too, can play an essential role in maintaining morale, particularly during long-term leaves. Ensuring employees are informed about their benefits can alleviate anxiety and promote a sense of security.

Addressing any signs of leave abuse promptly and fairly can also contribute to maintaining high morale. It assures employees that everyone is treated equitably, reinforcing a positive work environment.

Ensuring smooth transitions & continuity for the team 

Tracking leave requests, encompassing parental, sick or paid vacation absences, HR teams can strategically plan staffing requirements and efficiently reallocate tasks among the remaining staff members.

This enables smooth operations and optimal utilization of resources even in the face of employee absences. This proactive approach minimizes unwelcome surprises and keeps the team on the same page.

The leave management process should also provide as much notice as possible for long-term leaves. This allows employees and managers to make informed decisions about workload distribution, ensuring no one is overwhelmed or left in a lurch.

Companies must manage employee leave in a way that respects laws such as the Medical Leave Act and labor laws to avoid legal trouble. Taking clear records of leave with a leave management software can assist in this regard.

Maintaining continuity and smooth transitions is about managing tasks, relationships, and expectations. Regular communication with the employee on leave and the rest of the team is essential to address any concerns and keep morale high.


Managing employee leave presents a set of challenges that requires thoughtful attention and strategic management. A comprehensive and efficient system to handle leave requests and balances is essential to prevent inconsistencies and inaccuracies. 

Staffing and workload balance is paramount during leave periods, ensuring productivity remains unhindered, and the team's workload is evenly distributed.

Legal compliance and adherence to organizational policies can pose significant challenges. Navigating complex labor laws and regulations while aligning with internal leave policies requires knowledge and tools, such as automated HR software.

Unexpected or prolonged leaves add a layer of complexity, necessitating robust contingency plans, clear communication channels, and considerations for team dynamics.

The aspect of employee engagement and retention must be noticed. Maintaining high morale, ensuring smooth transitions, and continuity of roles during leave periods are key components in retaining your workforce. 

Addressing these challenges effectively can result in more efficient leave management, increased productivity, improved legal compliance, and enhanced employee satisfaction.

Successful leave management is all about tracking time off and strategic planning, communication and employee support.

Ready to try Scribe?

Scribe automatically generates how-to guides and serves them to your team when they need them most. Save time, stay focused, help others.